State offering $700,000 for public defense; county responds ‘maybe’

musicWave

After about three hours of discussion split between morning and afternoon, the Mariposa County Board of Supervisors told staff Tuesday, Nov. 10 to pursue $700,000 in state money to hire someone to oversee public defense, a job no one in county government does now.

They reached a consensus to have staff submit a proposal to the Office of the State Public Defender (OSPD) before its Nov. 25 deadline. However, no votes were cast in favor or against the grant in the meeting.

They steered away from the public defender’s office the agenda item proposed and toward a “managed assigned counsel” model.

The agenda item, brought by Supervisor Rosemarie Smallcombe, asked whether staff should work with OSPD on a Mariposa Public Defender Office modeled on Mono County’s approach.

The Legislature allocated the money at the county’s request, spread over three years. In a managed assigned counsel system, a county employed attorney administers the system and assigns cases instead of running an office with staff attorneys.

OSPD told the county it is flexible on the model and wants a “proof of concept,” Smallcombe said.

The board directed staff to work with the county’s current contract attorneys on a job description, to have those attorneys interview applicants and choose the finalist and to report back to the board quarterly. The position would be written as tied to the grant. Supervisors stressed they can back out if it isn’t working.

The county has 14 public defense attorneys: three flat-fee contract attorneys and 11 conflict attorneys.

Conflict attorneys are used when the contracted attorneys cannot take a case because of a conflict of interest or other circumstances .

CAO Joe Lynch said the county spent $577,000 on public defense in 2023 and about $900,000 last year, and that spending now approaches $1 million a year with no one reviewing it.

“I would say from an administrator standpoint, we need it,” he said.

An estimate from supervisor Smallcombe put first-year costs of a managed assigned counsel attorney, assistant and startup at about $374,000, with general fund costs of roughly $205,000 a year after the grant if the county doesn’t renew one flat-fee contract.

State law is pushing the issue. AB 690 requires counties to collect workload data on indigent defense and submit contracts to OSPD by Jan. 1, 2028. AB 2605 adds reporting requirements by Jan. 1, 2029. Smallcombe said 22 of 24 contract-model counties she reviewed include some county oversight.

Not everyone was sold. Mariposa County Superior Court Judge Michael Fagalde, a former deputy public defender who has been a judge for nearly 12 years, said the state’s workload study recommends an administrator, not an office, and that an administrator can’t approve expert or investigator costs, which judges decide.

He said AB 690’s data requirements can be written into existing contracts and called cost recovery from defendants unrealistic. OSPD is “advisory only,” he said, and “holding money out in front of you.” Public defender Rick Squaglia cautioned that “you have a functioning defense bar that you could blow up and lose.”

Supervisor Shannon Poe said he worries about leaving an employee without a job after three years.

“This county is not doing well financially,” he said, adding, “I don’t think I could support that.”

Supervisor Jenni Kiser, who questioned the cost math, said she worries current public defenders may leave.

She repeated Fagalde’s point that the plan “isn’t going to save us money.”

Supervisor-elect Lisa Edelheit asked what the county would be obligated to do if it takes the grant.

Smallcombe said it’s a three-year pilot with no obligation beyond that.

“We’re all really struggling to make a decision,” Poe said.

Responses (0)

    Related posts

    featured
    Kellie FlanaganK
    Kellie Flanagan
    ·November 19, 2026

    Shop local, give art at Dec. 5 sale

    featured
    Kellie FlanaganK
    Kellie Flanagan
    ·November 19, 2026

    EASTERN MADERA HAPPENINGS

    featured
    Kellie FlanaganK
    Kellie Flanagan
    ·November 19, 2026

    Oakhurst veteran leads team to all 54 congressional offices

    featured
    Kellie FlanaganK
    Kellie Flanagan
    ·November 19, 2026

    High-speed chase ends with arrest

    More from author

    featured

    North Fork Mono Tribe leads cultural burn over 10 acres at China Meadow

    Kellie Flanagan·November 19, 2026
    featured

    All aboard the Holiday Magic Train, set to take off on Nov. 21

    Kellie Flanagan·November 19, 2026