In the Oct. 29 Mariposa Gazette, there was an opinion/editorial titled ‘Guns by themselves don’t kill or murder anyone’ I believe it was written to bolster the power of the Second Amendment, as it referenced “the right to bear arms.”
In this article there were many points made and written as fact but with research through the internet, books and historical accounts that I have read, many of the points were only opinion but gave the perception as fact.
While I realize everyone is entitled to their opinion, an editorial is written to air one’s personal feelings, I don’t believe an editorial should be written to foment fear or sway a reader to believe a false narrative.
1. Claim: In 1492 Spain’s Inquisition murdered 300,000 Jews who would not convert to the Catholic Church. While targeting any group of people is horrible, according to Wikipedia, Google, PBS, amuseum.org, ANU Museum of the Jewish People and others, approximately 180,000 Jewish people were persecuted and forced to leave Spain. Of the remaining Jewish people, an estimated “tens of thousands” died from exposure, starvation or attacks by bandits.
2. Claim: In Spain, for the last 83 years, with their gun control laws, they have successfully murdered 122.5 million people. Murder for any reason is abhorrent. According to many sources found on the internet, this is “mathematically impossible based on Spain’s population figures.” The population of Spain at its highest point (currently) is roughly 48 million people.
3. Claim: In 1929, the Soviet Union established full gun control and murdered 40 million people over a 24-year period. According to various sources including the New York Times and Encyclopedia Britannica, there may have been up to 400,000 deaths from war, famine and forced deportations; not 40 million.
4. Claim: In 1935 Communist China, China murdered 50 million people over a seven year period. During this period of time (Sino-Japanese war 1937-1945), Japan was in conflict with China and inflicted 14 to 20 million Chinese deaths. This idea that China caused this massive death of innocent lives and not Japan is attributed to Chairman Mao who ruled from 1949-1976 who did not manage the 1942 Henan Famine and the Yellow River flood of 1938 very well, and caused many people to die. In other words, water and lack of water killed many people. Additionally, chairman Mao was a ruthless dictator and did kill many of his own people through famine, cultural revolution, executions, labor camps and persecution.
5. Claim: From 1939 to 1945, Nazi Germany had full gun control and murdered over 18.6 million people. This is false according to Wikipedia, State of Wyoming Legislature, Scholarship Archive, Holocaust Encyclopedia and others. Hitler actually loosened many restrictions on long guns for ordinary German citizens and completely deregulated gun ownership and removed required permits. During this period, Germany murdered Jewish, Soviet, Romani, Serbians, the disabled and any person the government felt was an “enemy.” Roughly speaking, 11 million people were murdered and the remaining 8.6 million deaths were from World War II.
6. Claim: In Cuba from 1960 to 1983 the Cuban genocide murdered 150,000 people. According to Human Rights Watch, Human Rights Foundation, American Enterprise Institute and Genocide Watch, approximately 11,000 specific victims have been identified. There were 5,600 by firing squad, 1,200 assassinations and the rest who died from exposure, drowning or starvation.
7. Claim: There were over a million people murdered in Cambodia from 1973 to 1986 with gun control in force leaving the population unable to fight back. According to Wikipedia, Holocaust Museum of Houston, USC Shoah Foundation and the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS), the timeline and gun control is inaccurate, as the Cambodian Civil War took place between 1967-1975. There was no gun control in place and in fact the country had a proliferation of military-grade small arms from France, U.S., Chinese and the Soviet Union. Pol Pot was a ruthless dictator and was in power from 1975 through 1979 and did murder up to a million people.
8. Claim: In 1994 Rwanda, Hutus murdered up to one million people utilizing guns and having gun control. According to Amnesty International, the Holocaust Memorial Museum, the BBC, CBS and Wikipedia, while there were guns used, most of the murders that occurred were with basic farm tools and implements like machetes, axes, hoes, clubs and bow and arrows.
9. Claim: the article states America is the only nation that allows its people to have guns “which has protected us for over 245 years.” As of this month, October of 2026, there have been 343 mass shootings across 40 states and there are enough guns in the U.S. for every man, woman and child to have a gun. Private gun ownership is allowed in Mexico, Guatemala, Switzerland, Czech Republic, Canada, New Zealand, Russia and most European countries such as Germany, France, Finland, Italy and Spain. According to Congress.gov, National Institute of Health, Johns Hopkins School of Public Health, Centers for Disease Control, Yale School of Medicine, Kidsdata and others in the U.S., firearm-related injuries are the leading cause of death among children ages 1-19. Where is the protection?
10. Claim: In 1929-33 the stock market crashed due to Franklin D. Roosevelt and the Democratic Party. With the Biden presidency, we have many similarities today, and it’s about to happen again. The factual date and timeline was that the Republican President Herbert Hoover presided over the Great Depression. Herbert Hoover was elected into office on March of 1929 and the stock market crashed in October of 1929.
The Great Depression lasted throughout Hoover’s presidency (four years). It was actually the Democratic President Franklin D. Roosevelt who rescued the country out of the depression with the “New Deal” plan. This plan stabilized banks, left the gold standard, provided relief and jobs and regulated the economy.
Currently, we have a Republican president in the White House and have so for approximately 23 months. According to Gallup polls, Wikipedia, Quora, Pew Research Center, and U.S. House of. Representatives Archives, the country has done better under the metrics of GDP Growth, stock market returns, personal income growth, job growth, unemployment rates, inflation, and federal budget deficits under a Democratic president than a Republican president.
The current president is the only president since Herbert Hoover to have negative job growth in their term as president.
11. Claim: For the last 48 years, the Democratic Party, along with the Muslims we have in our government today, wants to destroy the greatest Constitution the world has ever seen. As far as Muslims becoming politicians in the U.S., there are currently five elected by their constituents. Abdul Mohamed El-Sayed will be the sixth and will begin his term this next year. Additionally, Dr. Mehmet Oz who is the 17th Administrator of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services is a practicing secular Muslim working under Republican president Donald J. Trump.
The constitution according to many historians and scholars was written by at least 55 delegates through debate, effort, compromise with many hours of deliberation and borrowed from several other well written documents such as the English Bill of Rights and the Magna Carta.
One of the primary writers, James Madison, was the author and writer of the U.S. Constitution and the Bill of Rights and crafted the Establishment Clause (Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion). The intent was keeping the government separate from religious affairs. He was not alone, Thomas Jefferson, Thomas Paine, Ethan Allen, George Washington and Benjamin Franklin advocated strongly on this same principle.
The Second Amendment was written and ratified a full four years after the Constitution and it is extremely important to cite the full wording: “A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.”
In 1636, the Massachusetts Bay Colony organized the first colonial citizen-militia. This slowly evolved into the National Guard and in 1903, the Militia Act of 1903 along with the National Defense Act of 1916 standardized the federal-state hybrid structure of the National Guard. These Acts were developed to serve as local citizen-soldier militia as stated in the Second Amendment, also known as a “well regulated militia.” In California there are approximately 25,000 members of the California and National Guard members.
Many atrocities can be attributed to the power of the gun. Unfortunately, the author is correct, guns don’t kill people; people kill people. The article mentioned several genocides in our history but was amiss to mention the worst one.
That would be the calculated eradication of the Native American population of North America. At this point in time, this is the worst genocide ever recorded according to many historians. Quite simply, laws were written and soldiers were sent out with guns to enforce the laws.
With the exception of John Quincy Adams, most early presidents oversaw the laws that helped to destroy native tribes. True natives in North America are now at about 1.1-2 percent of their original numbers since colonization began.
Michael Wallich is a resident of Mariposa.










Responses (0)